Podcast: Play in new window | Download | Embed
In just a little over an hour Thursday, an Anchorage jury reached a guilty verdict in the trial of Brian Smith, accused of killing two Alaska Native women.
They convicted Smith on all fourteen counts in the deaths of Kathleen Jo Henry and Veronica Abouchuk.
Rhonda McBride from our flagship station KNBA reports.
During the three-week trial, police and prosecutors showed how Smith preyed upon their vulnerability.
Both women came from small communities in Western Alaska and struggled with homelessness and addiction in Anchorage.
Henry was 30 and Abouchuk, 52.
In the final moments of the trial, the prosecution recapped scenes from videos and photos stored on an SD card, which showed Henry being tortured and strangled.
Police said someone found the card on the ground labeled, “Homicide at the midtown Marriott.”
The voice of a man could be heard in the footage with a thick South African accent, which police connected to Smith as he was under investigation in different case.
Debate over the memory card was a source of contention throughout the trial, as well as the credibility of Valerie Casler, the woman who gave it to police.
During her testimony, Casler changed her story – and said the footage actually came from a cell phone she stole from Smith’s pick-up truck and copied to the SD card.
Smith’s attorney Timothy Ayers argued in closing statements that Casler’s testimony alone was enough to give the jury reasonable doubt.
“Whether she wanted the limelight. Whether she wanted to hide something. Whether she doesn’t have a good memory. She is a very comfortable and constant liar, and there is reasonable doubt there.”
But Heather Nobrega, co-counsel for the prosecution, asked the jury to consider the totality of the evidence, which included cell phone data, text messages, surveillance footage, and video from another cellphone police seized from Smith which showed him toying with Abouchuk’s dead body.
“The defendant violently and brutally murdered two women. That is why we are here today. That is why the state is asking you to convict Smith of the crimes charged — and that the state has proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt. Thank you.”
Throughout the duration of the trial, they said they hoped their presence would send a message of strength and caring, but, most important of all, bring justice.
In Modoc County, Calif., Jarrett Rucker, a non-Native man, is on trial accused of killing Pit River tribal member Milton Patrick McGarva, who was found stabbed to death in his home in 2020.
Rucker is charged with first-degree murder.
As Frank Sterling reports, advocates for missing and murdered Indigenous people says this is an important case.
The trial began with prosecutor Barton Bowers revealing that Milton McGarva, Yogi as he was known, and Jarrett Rucker were in a romantic relationship and had been living together in McGarva’s rural home for approximately two years before Yogi was killed.
Bowers also described the scene of the killing as brutal.
Numerous witnesses were called, including first responders and McGarva’s family.
His family painfully recalled the tragedy, saying McGarva had just pulled through some serious health challenges.
Russell McGarva is one of Yogi’s brothers.
“He had 13 different surgeries and he made it through it. You know, and to be taken away the way he was from us, it’s just not right.”
Geraldine McGarva, Yogi’s sister, says he was a community-oriented man and loved to help out.
“Fun loving guy that made everybody laugh when he was around. We all laughed and joked and kidded with each other. He helped everybody out.”
Advocate Morning Star Gali of the organization Indigenous Justice says this is an important case for Native people.
“There has actually been charges put forward in terms of a non-Native individual against a tribal member is something that’s unheard of out here and something that’s really significant in our seek for justice for the families and for all (MMIP) cases. These cases, the majority of them never actually make it to this point that go to trial.”
The trial is expected to wrap up next week with the testimony of the medical examiner and closing arguments by the attorneys before the case is turned over to the jury.
Get National Native News delivered to your inbox daily and stay up-to-date on the 2024 Native Vote. Sign up for our daily newsletter today.